This Chocolate Italian Ice recipe is a guest post by Faith Kramer of Blog Appetit from her days with Sugar Savvy. It was hot, muggy and steamy on the streets of New York during my recent visit. How did I keep my cool and enjoy a treat without suffering a chocolate meltdown? Why, I just indulged in a refreshing chocolate Italian ice. Italian ices are well known on the East Coast, especially in the Mid-Atlantic states. They are smoother than granitas, softer than sorbets and just generally different. They are also incredibly refreshing.
Chocolate Italian Ice that’s Close to Authentic
While I ate Italian ices throughout my youth and as an adult on periodic visits back East, I really didn’t know much about them. I did a quick web search on the history and differences but I have to say I was left a bit confused about the difference between an Italian ice and an Italian water ice.
Some sources use both terms interchangeably, others say there is a difference. An Italian ice is flavored, then frozen and shaved for serving. An Italian water ice is plain ice that is flavored after it has been shaved into soft, snowy mounds, except when it is not and then it is the same as an Italian ice. Regional differences among Italian immigrants and American cities probably account for the differences in technique and nomenclature.
Italian immigrants to this county brought with them a long tradition of frozen desserts including granita (made by freezing water, fruit juices or other flavoring ingredients and sugar in a pan and periodically flaking and scraping the ice as it forms to break up the ice crystals) and sorbet (made by freezing similar ingredients in a ice cream freezer). Commercial Italian ice makers proudly list their flavors made from natural fruit and other flavors. Lemon and cherry are traditional flavors but modern tastes range from melon to mango, chocolate to green tea.
What they don’t list is how they make their treat. Food historians say it started as frozen blocks of sweetened fruit flavors shaved into small, white pleated paper cups. As the ice melted, eaters could squeeze the cup to get the last of their ice. While the pleated cup is still the traditional method of serving Italian ice, nowadays more and more vendors are serving the treat in sturdier disposable bowls with spoons.
My chocolate Italian ice was delicious, with a clean, dark chocolate taste. Although it was made without any milk products it was incredibly rich yet not the least bit heavy. It was the perfect summertime treat.
Here is a recipe for a chocolate ice I adapted from a cookbook I picked up in a used bookstore, The Complete Book of Homemade Ice Cream by Carolyn Anderson. It was published in 1972, and is no longer in print, but used copies can still be found. This isn’t an “authentic” chocolate Italian ice recipe, but it is close, especially if you serve it before hardening it in the freezer.
Special Diet Notes: Chocolate Italian Ice
By ingredients, this recipe is dairy-free / non-dairy, egg-free, gluten-free, nut-free, peanut-free, soy-free, vegan, vegetarian, and top food allergy-friendly.
Chocolate Italian Ice
Ingredients
Method
- Boil the sugar and water together for five minutes and then remove from the heat. Immediately add the cocoa and cinnamon. Mix well.
- Let it cool a bit and then refrigerate until cold.
- Freeze in an ice cream freezer as per manufacturer’s instructions.
- Serve straight from the ice cream maker container for a softer ice or place in the freezer for a few hours to harden the ice. Another option is to pour the chilled chocolate ice mixture into ice cube trays and freeze. Before serving, process the ice cubes in small batches in a blender or food processor until the chocolate ice mixture is thoroughly broken up but not yet slushy.
Nutrition
Notes
Tried this recipe?
Let us know how it was!More Naturally Dairy-Free Frozen Desserts
Pineapple Orange Sorbet
Berry Watermelon Pops
Black Grape Sorbet
15 Comments
I followed exactly as directed and mine was still completely liquid when the cuisines ice cream maker cycle ended.
Hi Shawn, unfortunately this would be an issue with the ice cream maker or preparation of the machine, not with the recipe. If your machine has an insert, it must be fully frozen. To do this, it must be in your freezer for 24 to 48 hours, and removed when you are prepping the machine to churn. If it doesn’t have an insert, there might be an issue with the cooling mechanism. Water-based sorbets and ices can and do set up in ice cream makers if the machine is prepped and working as it should.
Hi! Can this be made with a sugar substitute?
If you mean a sugar-free sugar substitute, then no, I don’t recommend it. Sugar softens ice cream in a way that sugar-free subs cannot. It will end up like hard ice water without any sugar. If you simply what to substitute a more natural sweetener, like maple syrup, that can still work. There just need to be actual sugars.
Was in search for a Delicious Chocolate Italian Ice since the Authentic Italian stores shut down yrs ago and this comes close! Hit the spot. Thanx so much its Delicious.
Glad you enjoyed it Taylor!
😋🍨
Calorie content per serving? Can I make this and put in a plastic bag and eat like a slushy? Or would that require alcohol?
You can use the plastic bag / salt method. It will be slushy like. Or you can freeze in cubes and blend for a slushy effect.
I like that you mentioned that despite being dairy free, this ice recipe still managed to capture the bitter dark chocolate taste. I’m thinking about opening an ice cream shop in the future and I think it would be great if I expanded to shaved ice products and dairy-free menu items as well. Perhaps I should allot some of my capital to buying a shaved ice machine and see what I can do with it.
Loved this recipe but thought it was a bit sweet. Mixed in half cup less sugar and also a combination of cocoa and special dark cocoa for a very rich great tasting treat. Do you have any other recipes/flavors? Do you know what the difference of cream ice?
Glad it worked out so well for you Jordan and thank you for the feedback. We don’t have other “ice” recipes, but if you are looking for more dairy-free ice cream recipes, this post includes 31 different flavors / recipes -> https://godairyfree.org/news/dairy-free-ice-cream-recipes We also have various sorbet recipes, which are a bit like Italian ice. Those are on this search -> https://godairyfree.org/?s=sorbet – the recipes are intermixed with reviews, you can see them as you scroll. I hope that helps!
Your understanding of Italian ice and water ice is completely wrong. I will first start with water ice or wooder ice as pronounced in phili. Water ice is made in the same machines used to make ice cream and other frozen products. This machine is a batch freezer. Water ice is served at a very soft consitanicy at around 18deg. The product is made with either fruit or extracts, sugar, and water. If eaten the traditional way You do not use a spoon. Now for Italian ice. Italian ice is served a little harder then water ice. The product is made the same way with a batch freezer using the same ingredients. There is no shaving involved at all. Buy local homemade ice there are lots if companies such as Rita’s, or Via Veneto these products are trash. They offer high fructose corn syrup and use way to many stabilizers giving you a gummy texture ( via Veneto) if you want real ice check out some local spots like the lemon ice king of corona, or johns water ice in Phili.
I made the chocolate Italian ice this evening. Fast, easy and yummy.
Awesome! Thank you for your feedback Mark.